Should Principal / teacher hit students?
-
x 3Originally posted by starcom:x2
Yeah... I remember I used to have Round 2 of canning if I were to tell my parents that I got scolded or canned by teacher.
Some students nowadays are really rebellious and uncontrolled. Sadly, some of these student parents also behave in an idiotic way thinking that it is not the teachers jurisdiction to punished these students. I think these people really lack foresight.
In Chinese San Zhi Jing, ‘.. xue bu jiao, shi zhi guo...’, if the student is does not learnt (or behave, it’s the failure of the teacher to discipline them. Was I angry with the teacher that disciplined me, probably yes at that time but also through those disciplinary actions that I respected them and in my later years, I am grateful to them cause the kept me from straying. Though I am no body great now, I sure thank the teachers for their teaching.
I also think the MOE should not have accepted his resignation. This will only singled to the public that teachers should not discipline students. This will also demoralize the teachers and educators for Christ sake.
However, the punishment should be using cane and should not use hand to slap. I am not sure how true if it was the case that the principle slapped the student. But I think probably the student deserved it!!! DamnÂ… if I were him, I probably KTV her.
-
err....simi si KTV?Originally posted by starcom:x2
Yeah... I remember I used to have Round 2 of canning if I were to tell my parents that I got scolded or canned by teacher.
Some students nowadays are really rebellious and uncontrolled. Sadly, some of these student parents also behave in an idiotic way thinking that it is not the teachers jurisdiction to punished these students. I think these people really lack foresight.
In Chinese San Zhi Jing, ‘.. xue bu jiao, shi zhi guo...’, if the student is does not learnt (or behave, it’s the failure of the teacher to discipline them. Was I angry with the teacher that disciplined me, probably yes at that time but also through those disciplinary actions that I respected them and in my later years, I am grateful to them cause the kept me from straying. Though I am no body great now, I sure thank the teachers for their teaching.
I also think the MOE should not have accepted his resignation. This will only singled to the public that teachers should not discipline students. This will also demoralize the teachers and educators for Christ sake.
However, the punishment should be using cane and should not use hand to slap. I am not sure how true if it was the case that the principle slapped the student. But I think probably the student deserved it!!! DamnÂ… if I were him, I probably KTV her. -
The conclusion isOriginally posted by FireIce:there was a debate on this a few yrs ago........
a teacher-student rship is a transaction.........students (parents) pay the teacher to teach......so students have a "control" over the teachers....anything the student dun like or thinks tt the teacher shd not be doing this to them, they can complain.....and bcos MOE want face.......most of the time the teachers kena badly even though it's the students/parents man bu jiang li......
Some Singaporean parents' think they rich can do anything.
MOE KiaSi.
Because of dis, students getting more rebellious and also therefore lead to their way of protest also easy led to committing suicide. -
Ya precisely!Originally posted by NeonTetra:those days...parent see teacher can his/her child...go home yet another round of caning leh. now....use book and 'bless' her head also kena complained.
and if not can even not think of going home..
my bro's time my father use to chain my bro and use belt to beat, -
chinese saying...Originally posted by NeonTetra:err....simi si KTV?
K ta yi tun --- beat her up good
Ti ta yi jiao --- kick her
then show her the V sign -
warow.. nowadays students.... cannot make it la
-
but then using belt is a bit too abusive lah...Originally posted by IamAngeline:Ya precisely!
and if not can even not think of going home..
my bro's time my father use to chain my bro and use belt to beat, -
use belt is considered good liaozOriginally posted by coolger03:but then using belt is a bit too abusive lah...
My neighbour was being stripped naked and left alone outside by his mother, lucky my parents go n persuade the mum.. -
Originally posted by IamAngeline:use belt is considered good liaoz
My neighbour was being stripped naked and left alone outside by his mother, lucky my parents go n persuade the mum..
so serious..
my mom would chase me all over the house with her 'heavenly sword' as I try to dodge her strokes , but think back now actually glad that she did so 
-
My heart goes out for this P ! Work in teaching line since 1975 I also not yet born, all those years of service gone down with one book slapping on a student. What the Cow lah!!!
Sometimes keeping a problematic student in your school has its repercussion, never be grateful, somemore can cause P to resign! Damn!!
Last time i sleep in class, teacher see take the board duster (soft type) throw at my head! Go home show my father got Oh Bak Kak, some more got second round of rotan!!!
sigh... gone were the days parents respected teachers! -
i detest and resent parents who use disproportionate and excessive force on their children - whatever the children have done.Originally posted by IamAngeline:use belt is considered good liaoz
My neighbour was being stripped naked and left alone outside by his mother, lucky my parents go n persuade the mum.. -
Hmph. Those insolence child abusing fools, in recent years when my parents try to beat me, I'll break the cane and throw it in their face. Children got to learn to protect themselves too.
-
hahahhaha.. this is cute.Originally posted by ChrisYX:
so serious..
my mom would chase me all over the house with her 'heavenly sword' as I try to dodge her strokes , but think back now actually glad that she did so -
u break it into 2, now they hav 2 canes to work on you liaoOriginally posted by Ayukat:Hmph. Those insolence child abusing fools, in recent years when my parents try to beat me, I'll break the cane and throw it in their face. Children got to learn to protect themselves too. 
______________________
I am Croco, Croco am I
Croco Movie -
wha....humiliation leh.Originally posted by IamAngeline:use belt is considered good liaoz
My neighbour was being stripped naked and left alone outside by his mother, lucky my parents go n persuade the mum.. -
wow...poor brother.Originally posted by IamAngeline:Ya precisely!
and if not can even not think of going home..
my bro's time my father use to chain my bro and use belt to beat,
how's he doing now?
-
Haha rem last time my pri sch got a chinese teacher, he used 2 pull e "tail" (back of head) of boys in my class who were notti... Seems like v pain liddat...Originally posted by IamAngeline:last time we have even worst punishment than these...
use cane lah, use ruler hit palm, pull guy's sideburn and kanna kok on the head...
and mummy still present to see teacher hit the kids, still saying, "nvm go ahead n punish'
nowaday students are getting .... haiz...
parents also getting kia si
anyway unless it those very terrible abusing... but just use a soft cover to hit the head nia.. y make such a big fuss -
Why not? Hit loh. Preferably with a really thick, hard cover book. Soft cover books are for wusses. Students really deserve a lesson these days.
-
My mother said that too, so I threw it into the dustbin.Originally posted by sgboy2004:u break it into 2, now they hav 2 canes to work on you liao
______________________
I am Croco, Croco am I
Croco Movie -
Originally posted by Ayukat:My mother said that too, so I threw it into the dustbin.
did she resort to bamboo pole? -
Haiz, no wonder you turn out like that.Originally posted by Ayukat:Hmph. Those insolence child abusing fools, in recent years when my parents try to beat me, I'll break the cane and throw it in their face. Children got to learn to protect themselves too. 
-
No, she wouldn't dare.Originally posted by NeonTetra:
did she resort to bamboo pole? -
Of course she wouldn't dare. Its an absolute waste on you.Originally posted by Ayukat:No, she wouldn't dare. -
I'll call the police if she did that.Originally posted by ditzy:Of course she wouldn't dare. Its an absolute waste on you. 
-
hahah he just got himself n gf registered this morning in VancouverOriginally posted by NeonTetra:wow...poor brother.
how's he doing now?