SG spy on Aussie & Thai military facilities?
-
---http://www.nationmultimedia.com/2007/01/23/headlines/headlines_30024843.php
Professor Ball, from the Australian National University in Canberra, is a world authority on signals intelligence. A regular visitor to Thailand and Southeast Asia, he has strong links with the Thai military...
(Aussie)
Prof Ball said Australia went through a similar debate five years ago when Singtel purchased the Optus mobile phone company. He was one of a series of analysts who publicly opposed the takeover. The Australian government eventually allowed the sale to go through, partly to ensure continued close cooperation with the island state, but Australia had to spend a huge sum on fibre-optic cables to avoid use of the Optus satellite and ensure its defence communications were secure.
Part of the problem, Ball said, was "Singapore have a track record of taking advantage of information for commercial and political purposes" - as did the US, and former Soviet Union.
Singapore had "listened to and photographed Australian military facilities", which had created diplomatic rifts, he said.
"They have a history of abusing their access to training in other facilities abroad.
"That is not what friends are supposed to do - they abused their friendship," Ball said......
(Thailand)
Singapore already had an extensive array of satellite listening facilities, from a major base on Sentosa Island to listening equipment at the Thai Army base in Sai Yok - which Prof Ball said appeared to be "primarily focused on Thailand" - judging by the types of antennae he had seen there in recent years.
There were both HF (High Frequency) and VHF (Very High Frequency) antennae at the Singaporean compound at RTA base in Sai Yok, but he believed "the VHF is predominantly listening to Thailand" within a radius of 100-150km. A priority target might be a military base such as the Ninth Division and its associated units at Kanchanaburi.Professor Des Ball, also from the Strategic and Defence Studies Centre at the Australian National University but who gave evidence in his private capacity.Professor Ball has published many articles and books on Defence related issues, including a series of publications about Joint Defence Facilities in Australia. His writings on the Joint Defence Facility at Pine Gap are regarded as being authoritative.
--www.fas.org/irp/facility/Chapter3.htm
2.Lets see when opposition party in Aussie raise question
on SG spying on them!
3.SG MFA is really has a sense of humor!We do not know what General Sonthi's remarks meant. Domestic calls within Thailand are not routed through Singapore. It does not make business or technical sense to route domestic calls via another country. Doing so will incur additional and unnecessary network resources (including costly international bandwidth) and degrade the quality of service.
--- 22/01/2007,SG MFA Spokesman's Comments on Council for National Security Chief Sonthi Boonyaratglin's remarks about the impact of foreign ownership of telecommunication industry on national security -
And the United States doesn't have spy facilities and what not. Boo hoo.. they are spying on us.
Idiots. -
this is nothing new la
The spying capabilities of singapore is well known in this region antenna farm, satellite, etc.
So now with our economic might, we can buy and buy. -
FM hits back at Singapore over telephone tapping,24.01.2007
---http://www.nationmultimedia.com/2007/01/24/headlines/headlines_30024963.phpA war of words between Thailand and Singapore escalated on Wednesday after Singapore denied that it was spying on military leaders' phone conversations.
Singapore has denied the accusation made last week by Army Commander in Chief Gen Sondhi Boonyaratkalin that Singapore was snooping on their conversations through a telecommunications company that deposed Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra sold to the country last year.
Singapore's Foreign Ministry issued a statement Monday saying, "We do not know what Gen Sondhi's remarks meant." It added, "It does not make business or technical sense to route domestic calls via another country. Doing so will incur additional and unnecessary network resources, including costly international bandwidth, and degrade the quality of service."
Foreign Ministry's spokesman Kitti Wasinondh hit back Wednesday. "I am puzzled by the statement from Singapore's Foreign Ministry that they do not understand the remarks of Gen Sondhi. It is not appropriate for Singapore to issue such a statement."
"If Singapore wants clarification of the remarks, Singapore can send its ambassador to Gen Sondhi," the spokesman told reporters.
Sondhi said last week that the army has a problem now. "When we make a call, the line goes to Singapore. When we talk secrets, they go straight to Singapore."
The bickering started last week after Thai government expressed anger over Singapore's hospitality to ousted Prime Thaksin during a visit earlier this month. Thaksin met with Singapore's deputy prime minister, prompting Thailand to suspend a visit by Singapore's foreign minister. Bangkok called the meeting inappropriate given Thaksin's ouster from the government, but Singapore insisted that it was private visit between old friends. -
man this has been happening for years,and not just from Singapore,what do you think america does to every country in the world?they spy on everyone.besides,Singapore isn't a threat to Australia,we have government agreements and contracts that neither party would condsider breaking.plus....knowing how much australia is over run by the americans now,australia is most likely being used to spy on other countries! it will never stop...
-
"It is not appropriate for Singapore to issue such a statement"??
Oh wait, I forgot theirs is a military junta...
Of course, who are we to issue statements trying to argue our case against them? The impudence! (insert gasp)
Bah. Thank goodness my Bangkok trip's been put off.... -
It looks like General Sondhi isn't very familiar with Data Communication Systems and phones.
I don't have to bug the whole of Thailand to get secrets. I only need to bug a few key people. General Sondhi is one, that doesn't need bugging. I doubt there would be hardly intelligence* that could be gotten out of him. Pun intended. -
what farking antennas in sai yok ? ...
the SAF are so restricted over there, training troops can't even test fire weapons with blanks without pushing some papers to the RTAF, you think the RTAF will allow "antennas" to spring up like grass ah ? ...
arm chair experts .... ... 
-
the recent bombing of unused satelite by china exposes the countries using satelite to spy. those who gives a unpleasant reply to china govt are those who use satelite to spy. i suppose.
-
Frankly I don't blame the Australians or Thais for being suspicious of Singapore spying. The Australian government has not said anything so far officially .
Turn the table around and you will be yelling THEY COULD BE SPIES if someone foreign bought up the Singaporean telecommunications capability . So why are you whining about this matter, lionnoisy? -
Region under Lion's eyes 24/7?!
CRISP operates a satellite ground station to acquire data from remote sensing satellites, and processes the archived data to standard or value-added products for distribution and research. The list of satellites CRISP receive include:
--The Centre for Remote Imaging, Sensing and Processing (CRISP) is a research centre of the National University of Singapore established with funding from the Agency for Science, Technology & Research (A*STAR) of Singapore.
* SPOT 1,2,4 (since September 1995)
* ERS 1,2 (since March 1996)
* RADARSAT 1 (May 1997 - May 2000)
* SeaWiFS, NOAA and FengYun 1C (since September 1999)
* TERRA (MODIS) (since March 2001)
* IKONOS (since August 2001)
* EROS-A1 (since October 2001)
* AQUA (MODIS) (since July 2002)
* SPOT 5 (since October 2002) -
Dont want ppl to spy...dont sell....simple common sense
-
Now so high tech, anyone can spy on phonecalls as long as they can tap the satellite lah. Read more books lah little boys... know how telephone calls work in bigger countries lah little boys...
-
You dumb or what.. if thaksin want to sell you stop huh? Pls use your brain leh.Originally posted by Mid9Sun:Dont want ppl to spy...dont sell....simple common sense -
Bugging is last time technolgy, now lagi more high tech. I doubt you have intelligence too.Originally posted by Shotgun:It looks like General Sondhi isn't very familiar with Data Communication Systems and phones.
I don't have to bug the whole of Thailand to get secrets. I only need to bug a few key people. General Sondhi is one, that doesn't need bugging. I doubt there would be hardly intelligence* that could be gotten out of him. Pun intended. -
You see, the Thais are so bloody backward and lacking in credits they don't have the same kind of Electronic surveillance equipment. The Aussies definitely have, so that's why they don't say much.
What is certain is that we have such tech and we are actively using them. Just too bad the buggers have nothing equivalent. -
don't think anybody here is blaming the OZ (specifically the prof balls) or the Thais, just say that they are stupid.Originally posted by fymk:Frankly I don't blame the Australians or Thais for being suspicious of Singapore spying. The Australian government has not said anything so far officially .
Turn the table around and you will be yelling THEY COULD BE SPIES if someone foreign bought up the Singaporean telecommunications capability . So why are you whining about this matter, lionnoisy?
Thailand to date has got problem in so many areas, from Stock Market to Foreign Investment to Airport, they need to divert attention, same old political game. The prof Balls from Australia University is known to have close link with the thai military, was probably asked to say something to support them. Together they created a joke. The OZ government takes Balls remark as a private remark, so it is right that they say nothing.
everybody knows that thai military janta is an illegal government, with all they guns and tanks, they are unable to prosecute Thaksin or cancel his passport. Singapore may not have as many visitors here than Thailand, but surely there are already many spies coming in and out, how do you think they can spy on Singapore by buying up Singaporean telecomms capabilities? a bit costly isn't it? -
Originally posted by lionnoisy:
Everyone else have access too. These are all commercial satellites.
[b]Region under Lion's eyes 24/7?!
--The Centre for Remote Imaging, Sensing and Processing (CRISP) is a research centre of the National University of Singapore established with funding from the Agency for Science, Technology & Research (A*STAR) of Singapore.[/b] -
This is proper way to do ELINT or SGINT. No antenna farm required.
All you need is a van parked across the street. Who knows, if you are lucky you might get to view the user's p0rn.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TEMPEST -
It's not exactly high tech, it's very easy to do one as long as you got the dish, config code and some other things which I forgot.Originally posted by Fingolfin_Noldor:You see, the Thais are so bloody backward and lacking in credits they don't have the same kind of Electronic surveillance equipment. The Aussies definitely have, so that's why they don't say much.
What is certain is that we have such tech and we are actively using them. Just too bad the buggers have nothing equivalent. -
Really funny hor to see everyone here so angry about the thai government. If you all so against it don't just talk here lah, go protest against it lah, go and support thaksin lah. Let us all go to war with Thailand..
If you guys go war I also lanlan must go because of you guys KPKB.. lucky not all government like you idiots if not none stop fighting with each other because all want face only. -
Singaporean are used to be the second talking Cork winner in the last century but however due to the Special Traning by our Leaders we had become the number one winner . We can really be sure that no one can win us ever .
Singapore Shine against our neighbour , we always say that we are small but big with something . Har!!!!!!!!! That unconsious proudness never leave us .
For the Thailand situation with Singapore , I can feel that the people here would really like to stuck our personal big Gun to the Gen. throat so that he could not distort our relationship by his personal comment without any base of truth . If you ask me do we like to start a fight with such a fool-ly oldman then the answer is clear , Look at Taksin , he is staying away from him , letting him do whatever he want , say whatever he think , the pressure is on Soothi corner but he is not handling well so what's next ??? Think Soldier !! Think !!! Soothi is not someone who can be in politic , this is something the Educated People like us understand . For the Thais they have the Anti-Singapore feel all because of one man comment , they just don't care , these hardcore Thais loyal are nothing just as fool as soothi So why are we talking to fools while we can actually wait and see the real fight a few years later .
Just sharing .
Regards -
Yalor, let the thai settle their own problem lah, we kpkb for what... singaporeans unite!
-
Wah, botai boji u shoot me for wad?Originally posted by bigmouthjoe:Bugging is last time technolgy, now lagi more high tech. I doubt you have intelligence too. 
I'm also aware of more advanced SIGINT methods, just that I prefer the term "bugging" cannot ah? *growl* -
This Sonthi guy cannot solve his own country problem..look at wat is happening in S.Thailand. Getting worse off. Now this Sonthi guy wants to give more concession to the south thai rebels. Good luck to him...he need it...
For us Sg here, let the matter rest..It will be back to normal sooner or later. But not before this Sonthi guy farked up his country first..
In the meantime, me not going to Taik Lan in the forseeable future..why wanna go to Taik Lan when Sg is not welcome there?