Originally posted by coolant:It seems that the Chinese are beginning to lose control of its leash on North Korea. And now it seems even more dangerous, since North Korea has nuclear weapons. I do not think that China would want North Korea to be nuclear capable since N.K has a track record of disregard towards bilateral relations.
[b]China expressed OUTRAGE on NKÂ’s nuclear test.[/b]
I really dont understand what need is there for China to use its nukes on Taiwan and neither do i see a need for TW to go nuclear. If they ever do so, (they wont) China has all right to invade or rather reclaim taiwan. the chinese government has and always will view taiwan as its own. Only taiwan is playing around with the idea of being seperate from China.Originally posted by Black Aces:Looking at the NK (& possibly Iran's example), Taiwan already facing a near Mission Impossible task of successfully repelling a PLA invasion, may turn to nuclear weapons to deter an aggressive PLA posture against the island.
Personally, Taiwan should have nuclear weapons in its arsenal. None of Beijing leaders would want to go down in history as the Chinese leader who 'lost' Taiwan but I seriously doubt no Chinese leader would want to go down history as the person who lost Beijing, Shanghai & possibly another coastal city just to 'reclaim' Taiwan.
Thoughts anyone?
The explosion roughly equalled 550 tonnes of TNT. But for 550 Tonnes of TNT to cause a 4.2 earthquake. I believe public discussion believes otherwise.Originally posted by bigballs11:Actually hor, according to my spy sources, that so call "nuclear" explosion is created by a large underground TNT explosion. Every dick knows that US/Jap is more than happy to play along with NK, so the NK idiot think of this scarecrow plan will be assrim by KJ the second
Originally posted by storm_freaky13:Well storm, you are absolutely correct. There is definitely no need for China to use nukes on Taiwan (in the eventuality of an armed takeover of the island) as PLA numbers alone can overwhelm ROC numbers. I am toying, not promoting the idea mind you, that the Taiwanese taking a page out of the NK's reasonance of having nukes as self defence (against the US), will now be tempted to develop nuke weapons and using such weapons as a cornerstone as the main deterrant against superior PLA numbers. Remember, in the event of a PLA invasion of Taiwan, the latter knows it will be the 1st war (against PLA on Taiwanese soil) and last war, so the Taiwanese authorities have nothing to lose here. Imagine, if the taiwanese leaders gonna lose their country, might as well take Beijing, Shanghai down with it. Now if you are Beijing, will you make a move? You can but are you willing to pay the price (Taipei will not be the only city in ruins, but a nuked Beijing & Shanghai too?)
I really dont understand what need is there for China to use its nukes on Taiwan and neither do i see a need for TW to go nuclear. If they ever do so, (they wont) China has all right to invade or rather reclaim taiwan. the chinese government has and always will view taiwan as its own. Only taiwan is playing around with the idea of being seperate from China.
Well if you studied politics, you will realise that under current Taiwan political environment, it is not in the interest of Taiwan to just 'convert' from a national govt (ROC) to be a local govt (Taiwan SAR). As this thread is about NK nuclear test, I will not discuss this Taiwan/China issue here.
Originally posted by storm_freaky13:
For me i really hope Taiwan goes back to China perhaps under the S.A.R. just like Macau and HK. Afterall they are Chinese, they came from the mainland was together in the past so i see no reason why they want to be seperated...
Hmm I understand where you are coming from, good to learn from more experienced people like you Anyway i think in should TW actually bother buying Nukes, im sure beijing will do all it can to stop taiwan from obtaining it even if it calls for military force. Like what you said Beijing will not be willing to lose its capital or other major cities just to get back taiwan. Besides the Chinese local authorities view taiwan as their province so i believe if TW tries to obtain nukes, diplomacy will be first, if it fails an invasion is inevitable.Originally posted by Black Aces:Well if you studied politics, you will realise that under current Taiwan political environment, it is not in the interest of Taiwan to just 'convert' from a national govt (ROC) to be a local govt (Taiwan SAR). As this thread is about NK nuclear test, I will not discuss this Taiwan/China issue here.
Let me leave a thought for you and using your argument "... Afterall they are Chinese, they came from the mainland was together in the past so i see no reason why they want to be seperated..." , if Singapore was formerly part of Malaysia, do you agree Singapore should return to KL's (or even Putrajaya's) fold? Think about it....