The AH-1Z is a capable enough platform to replace the AS550 Fennec light attack choppers.Originally posted by Joe Black:I think 20 Apaches balance out the number of PT91 MAF is getting, 40 will put SAF in a commanding position.
Alternatively, RSAF can consider buying something cheaper like the AH-1Z or Eurocopter Tiger
well ... if the current trend is anything to go by ... methinks further purchases will be more apaches .... the SAF is trying to cut down the number of different platforms .... simplify logistics and training eh ...Originally posted by LazerLordz:The AH-1Z is a capable enough platform to replace the AS550 Fennec light attack choppers.
well, not everyone is impressed. See ST forum today:Originally posted by BillyBong:The way our sunday times glorifed the Apaches, make you wonder whether these writers know what they're writing or simply copying articles they read from other places.
Someone should tell them that over 4 Apaches were grounded by 'small arms fire' during the 2nd Iraq war...get it?
SMALL ARMS FIRE BROUGHT DOWN YOU GODLY APACHES!
*phew...had to let it out*
Never believe stories told by the Iraqi resistance forces... Not to mention that the press of any country is known to blow up small matters.Originally posted by BillyBong:The way our sunday times glorifed the Apaches, make you wonder whether these writers know what they're writing or simply copying articles they read from other places.
Someone should tell them that over 4 Apaches were grounded by 'small arms fire' during the 2nd Iraq war...get it?
SMALL ARMS FIRE BROUGHT DOWN YOU GODLY APACHES!
*phew...had to let it out*
erm...think you better watch more CNN then...the downing of the choppers was covered by their own media, not iraqis or comical ali...Originally posted by Delta 5:Never believe stories told by the Iraqi resistance forces... Not to mention that the press of any country is known to blow up small matters.
Many opponents of the USA like to spin tall tales about how they can bring them down, such as an Iraqi with an AK-47 shooting down an Apache for that matter, or China claiming it can destroy US Carrier battle Groups. Not that I am a supporter of the USA but can these countries at least make viable claims. A SA-10 or SA-15 system shooting down an Apache would perhaps be more believable.
The truth is that Apaches are immune to small arms fire of up to 7.62mm, resistant against 12.7mm fire and even with a 23/25/30 mm AA Gun bringing down a heavily armoured Apache is no mean feat.
The Hueys based in Sembawang have been decommissioned earlier this year. The only Hueys left in RSAF service are 5 or 6 based in Brunei, which will be similarly decommissioned by this year's end. I hope the RSAF would buy new utility and transport helos soon, either the UH-60L Blackhawk or the NH-90TTH.Originally posted by AF2005:sembawang better, chinooks, puma, huey and one very light one that i do not know the name. Addition of apache makes it more complete over the skys in the north.
well ... I have two CNN channels on my cable TV right now ... (plus a third one in spanish sucking away my money ) .... and i must say the only difference between comical ali and CNN is that one is an iraqi and the other's an american company .... I don't trust their journalistic integrity at all ... i guess their only motivation is to find the biggest, ugliest scandal of the day and report it .... and if it ruffles a few feathers or PO a few chaps all the better ... cos it meant that these very chappies will be tuning back to the channel seeking more of the same outrage ...Originally posted by BillyBong:erm...think you better watch more CNN then...the downing of the choppers was covered by their own media, not iraqis or comical ali...
And yes....intense small arms fire can down Apaches...never let their so-called invulnerability go to your head. All it takes is a lucky shot.
Care to share the site? hmmmm.....Originally posted by Fatum:was googling idly a while back when i stumbled onto this website that has supposed pics of the downed apaches ... they were troops on battle damage assesment teams or something ... and there were close-up shots of the damages ... consistent with heavy calibre cannon fire ... consistent with 37mm shell fire ....
are apaches invulnerable ... no, of course not ... you can bring down anything after all ... but did some iraqi soldier bring down an apache with an AK ? ... I guess probably not ....
twas a while back but i'll post the link as on my next break if i can find it ... if i remember correctly it was the strategy page or one of those sites ... they have some pretty nice pics there ... including a pic of a kiowa that made it back despite shell holes so numerous that it looked like cottage cheese ...Originally posted by BillyBong:Care to share the site? hmmmm.....
thats for most of the airframe. however if one of these rounds manage to make it into the turboshafts of the helicopter, it would cause damage to the powerplant and might probably cause the helicopter to go down.Originally posted by Delta 5:The truth is that Apaches are immune to small arms fire of up to 7.62mm, resistant against 12.7mm fire and even with a 23/25/30 mm AA Gun bringing down a heavily armoured Apache is no mean feat.
i'm just curious, anyone know why'd the designers add the cargo area to the Mi-24s? the hind is already not easily maneuverable due to its "wings" (weapon pylons)Originally posted by Shotgun:The Apaches I heard were only resistant up to 12.7mm fire. Another above 50 cal, depends on where it hits.
The Mi-24s however are different. Those are REALLY flying tanks.
It's actually the "iron bathtub", the cock.pit that is heavily armored to withstand up to 12.7mm shells.But metal being metal, concentrated and sustained fire will break it.Originally posted by sgFish:thats for most of the airframe. however if one of these rounds manage to make it into the turboshafts of the helicopter, it would cause damage to the powerplant and might probably cause the helicopter to go down.